Adrienne Barbeau (The Radio DJ (voice))
Hunter Smit (Sweet Tooth (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Cameron Easton (Timothy Blake (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Caroline Williams (Mrs. Blake (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Robert Rusler (Mr. Blake (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Clare Kramer (Lt. Brandt-Mathis (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Greg Grunberg (Alex Mathis (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Daniel DiMaggio (Mikey (segments "Sweet Tooth" & "Ding Dong"))
Austin Falk (Kyle (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Madison Iseman (Lizzy (segment "Sweet Tooth"))
Barry Bostwick (Mr. Abbadon (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell"))
Marcus Eckert (Billy (segment "The Night Billy Raised Hell"))